Patient engagement: a powerful tool with a powerful history

“Patient engagement” is a relatively recent term for patients becoming actively involved in their health care experience by educating themselves and working together with their doctors to make health care decisions. Sometimes it’s used as a buzzword to simply mean patients complying with what their doctors tell them to do. Among health care activists and advocates, though, it means patients actually working as partners with health care professionals. If you’re asking your doctor about genetic testing, if you’re reading blogs and visiting websites to figure out what you should know about lung cancer besides what your doctor has told you, or if you’re looking into clinical trials and making choices about them, you are an engaged patient.

You might hear the term “participatory medicine,” coined by Gilles Frydman (see http://participatorymedicine.org/). You might also hear the term “e-patient”: Tom Ferguson, MD, coined this term to describe patients who are “equipped, enabled, empowered, and engaged” in their own health and health care. (Also, the “e-” prefix, reminiscent of “e-mail,” intentionally connotes engaged patients’ use of the Internet to learn as much as they can and connect with one another).

Dave deBronkart, who calls himself “e-patient Dave,” has given a very moving and popular TEDx talk on patient engagement, “Let Patients Help” (see below) and has written a useful handbook by the same title (http://www.epatientdave.com/books/).

Patient engagement and participatory medicine are, of course, not really new at all. DeBronkart gives credit to “hippies” (he was one himself, and Tom Ferguson was the medical editor of the best-selling Whole Earth Catalog in the 1960s and 1970s). Patient engagement also owes a tremendous debt to the women’s health movement of the 1970s and 1980s, and the AIDS movement of the 1980s and 1990s. It was women’s health activists who first disseminated information about gynecological health for a lay audience, insisting that women had a right to be full partners with their doctors in making decisions about their bodies. It was AIDS activists who campaigned for, and won (among many other victories) the public database of clinical trials that has evolved into http://www.clinicaltrials.gov.

Conversations about lung cancer on patient engagement websites and in the #lcsm (Lung Cancer Social Media) tweetchats actually remind me a great deal of conversations about AIDS with ACT UP New York’s Treatment and Data Committee and its spinoff group Treatment Action Group in the 1990s. I used to be stunned, on an almost daily basis, at the scientific information non-scientists could understand and explain when their lives depended upon it.

Today, these conversations are happening online, using technology that barely existed 20 years ago, instead of face-to-face. This is a huge difference: it means that patients with rare diseases (or, say, common diseases with rare genetic mutations, like my own ROS1) can find one another and share resources, even if they don’t live anywhere near each other. When ACT UP people get together these days, we often say, “Imagine what we could have done if we’d had the Internet!” We usually mean we could have planned demonstrations to turn on a dime – but we could have helped a lot more people understand the newest AIDS research as well.

(There are other major differences, too, of course. ACT UP was rooted in vibrant queer urban subcultures, and joyously celebrated queer lives in a time when much of the country didn’t care if gay people died. ACT UP also had a strong social critique of the racial, economic, and gender inequities of the health care system, which so far I don’t really see among “e-patients”; some of us can be a little ignorant of how difficult it might be for a poor single mother with lung cancer to find the leisure time to explore clinical trials online.)

Here are some online history resources would-be “e-patients” may find inspiring:

I also highly recommend the following films: Jim Hubbard and Sarah Schulman’s United In Anger: A History of ACT UP (Los Angeles: The Film Collaborative, 2012), http://www.unitedinanger.com/ and David France’s How To Survive A Plague (New York: Sundance Selects: MPI Media Group, 2013), http://surviveaplague.com/. It’s a little easier to get your hands on How To Survive A Plague, but check academic libraries for United In Anger.

About Irene Elizabeth (Beth!) Stroud

Queer suburban mom, graduate student, lung cancer survivor, card-carrying United Methodist.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Patient engagement: a powerful tool with a powerful history

  1. I am just learning how to do this after spending the 1st 3 months post-diagnosis in a hazy daze feeling totally overwhelmed by both the diagnosis and treatment. And the chemo fog doesn’t help matters. But I’m starting to see the light at the end of the tunnel, and the brain fog is clearing a bit, (although I still have trouble finding the right words – frustrating for a writer!), and I’m starting to have more discussions with my treatment team. There are so many options now, which is wonderful, and more treatment options coming from research that are exciting. And having a medical background, I can understand most of what I’m reading on the research studies. Feeling very optimistic right now!

  2. Your experience, strength, and hope are amazing. It’s so great that you can relate your Act-Up experience to the current medical reality of lung cancer (and other v. serious illnesses) across the globe and social strata. I agree with you 100% that the “racial, economic, and gender inequities of the health care system” are not being addressed right now, and we need strong, knowledgeable voices like yours speaking the Truth. Thank you. Your Grace is an Inspiration.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s